Sunday, July 26, 2020

The Fifth Avenue Story Society ~ my review



The Fifth Avenue Story Society by Rachel HauckWhen five New Yorkers accept a mysterious, anonymous invitation to a story society, they begin a journey they could not have imagined and didn’t know they needed. Rachel Hauck’s five main characters arrive at a charming, historic library for the Fifth Avenue Story Society’s first meeting on September 9. They work past initial awkwardness, then meet weekly; and by March they have become trusted friends. During this time, they reveal secrets that have kept them stuck both personally and professionally.

In The Fifth Avenue Story Society, each modern-day participant’s backstory is compelling and each journey riveting. Hauck switches among five points of view every few pages. Usually, an author’s changing POV drives me crazy, but in this novel, Hauck’s doing so made the book unputdownable. I would just be falling deep into Jett’s personal grief or steaming over Lexa’s work frustrations or waxing nostalgic with Ed’s memories when I’d get interrupted by Coral’s plummeting profits or Chuck’s divorce drama. I was eager to read on to get back to progress in Jett's, Lexa's, and Ed's stories. But then I was eager to get back to Coral's and Chuck's, too.

Challenges for each of the five are multi-faceted. For example, Jett grapples with multiple family issues, a failed marriage, and a moral professional dilemma. This complexity added to my interest as well. Characters are well-rounded, and their emotions run true. I got impatient with two of the characters’ stall tactics, but apparently, stubbornness in relationships is one of Hauck’s themes in this novel.

Other themes in The Fifth Avenue Story Society include betrayal, moral compromise, anger, guilt, grief, honesty, love, courage, cowardice, and God’s love through Jesus Christ. The novel contains both romance and mystery. Each main character gets set free from his or her secrets, but the reveal for each is worth the reader's wait. The overarching mystery is who chose and invited them all to weave their stories together.

No comments: